The Making of St Anger by Metallica

Introduction

In the realm of heavy metal, few bands command as much attention and scrutiny as Metallica. When they released St. Anger in 2003, it was not just another album—it was a statement. Coming after a period of significant turmoil and transformation, St. Anger marked a departure from the band’s traditional sound, embracing raw production and aggressive themes. Its significance lies not only in its sonic experimentation but also in its reflection of the band’s internal struggles. This article will delve into the genesis, recording process, commercial performance, and lasting legacy of St. Anger, providing a comprehensive exploration of one of Metallica’s most polarizing works.

The album’s impact was immediate and divisive. As Lars Ulrich once noted, “It was a conscious decision to make a raw, aggressive record that would challenge our fans.” This was echoed by producer Bob Rock, who aimed to capture the band’s unrefined energy. Despite its mixed reviews, St. Anger debuted at number one on the Billboard 200 and earned Metallica a Grammy Award for Best Metal Performance. Its legacy endures, not just for its music but for what it represents in Metallica’s storied career.

The Genesis of “St. Anger”

To understand the genesis of St. Anger, one must first appreciate the tumultuous period that preceded its creation. The late 1990s saw Metallica experimenting with their sound, as evidenced by albums like Reload. However, the early 2000s were marked by significant internal strife, including the departure of bassist Jason Newsted and James Hetfield’s struggles with addiction. These events set the stage for a creative overhaul, leading to an album that would encapsulate the band’s raw emotion and reinvention.

Metallica’s evolution prior to St. Anger was defined by their willingness to push boundaries. Their self-titled 1991 release, often referred to as The Black Album, catapulted them into mainstream success, while Load and Reload saw them exploring new musical territories. Yet, it was the combination of personal and professional challenges that would most influence St. Anger. The departure of Newsted left a void, both musically and emotionally, that producer Bob Rock temporarily filled by playing bass during the recording sessions.

The album’s title, St. Anger, was a reflection of the turmoil within the band. The concept of anger as a purifying force was central to the album’s creation, with the artwork designed by Pushead, a long-time collaborator known for his distinctive, visceral style. The album cover, featuring a clenched fist bound by a rope, visually encapsulates the themes of frustration and entrapment that permeate the record.

The financial aspects of St. Anger were equally challenging. Funded by Elektra Records, the album’s budget was substantial, reflecting the band’s status but also the high expectations placed upon them. Despite these pressures, Metallica remained committed to producing an album that was true to their artistic vision, even if it meant eschewing traditional commercial appeal.

Recording Process

The recording of St. Anger was as unconventional as the album itself. Metallica’s HQ in San Rafael, California, served as the primary studio, a space that became both a sanctuary and a crucible for the band. The sessions began in April 2001 but were soon halted due to Hetfield’s rehabilitation. It wasn’t until May 2002 that the band reconvened, with Bob Rock taking on the dual role of producer and bassist.

Bob Rock, known for his work with Mötley Crüe and Metallica, brought his extensive experience to the table. His production style on St. Anger was intentionally raw, capturing the band’s live energy without the polish of overdubs. The recording sessions were marked by a focus on immediacy and authenticity, with minimal use of digital manipulation.

Challenges were abundant, from Hetfield’s restricted schedule post-rehabilitation to the band’s struggle to find a new bassist. Yet, these hurdles only added to the album’s raw energy. As Rock stated, “It was about capturing the moment, the emotion. That’s what St. Anger is all about.”

Bob Rock’s discography is extensive, showcasing his versatility and influence in the rock genre. Below is a table of some of the albums he produced:

Commercial Performance and Reception

Upon its release, St. Anger made an indelible mark on the charts, debuting at number one on the Billboard 200. This was a testament to Metallica’s enduring popularity, despite the album’s departure from their established sound. The album’s commercial success was further underscored by its performance on international charts, reaching the top spot in numerous countries.

The following table provides an overview of Metallica’s album sales, highlighting St. Anger among their discography:

In terms of accolades, St. Anger was awarded the Grammy for Best Metal Performance, further cementing its place in the annals of heavy metal history. Despite its success, the album faced stiff competition from other major releases of 2003, such as Meteora by Linkin Park and Fallen by Evanescence, both of which also made significant commercial impacts.

Other albums released in 2003 include:

• Meteora by Linkin Park [Physical Sales: 7,000,000]
• Fallen by Evanescence [Physical Sales: 8,000,000]
• Elephant by The White Stripes [Physical Sales: 2,000,000]
• Speakerboxxx/The Love Below by OutKast [Physical Sales: 5,500,000]

Ultimately, St. Anger garnered a range of awards and recognitions, reflecting both its divisive nature and its undeniable impact. The album’s double platinum certification by the RIAA attests to its widespread appeal and the fervent discussions it continues to inspire.

Singles and Track Analysis

The singles from St. Anger were instrumental in defining the album’s reception and commercial performance. Each release was a glimpse into Metallica’s creative process during a turbulent period, with tracks like “Frantic” and “Some Kind of Monster” encapsulating the album’s raw energy.

The following table provides an overview of the album’s tracklist, highlighting the songwriting credits and marking the singles:

Note: Tracks marked with * were released as singles. Chart positions include “Frantic” (#21 US Mainstream Rock), “St. Anger” (#2 US Mainstream Rock), “The Unnamed Feeling” (#28 US Mainstream Rock), and “Some Kind of Monster” (#18 US Mainstream Rock).

Influences and Legacy

The influences behind St. Anger were as varied as they were impactful. Drawing from genres like alternative metal and nu-metal, Metallica crafted an album that both challenged and defied expectations. The band’s experimentation with raw production and complex themes set the stage for a new era in heavy metal.

The following table outlines the influences on St. Anger and the artists it subsequently inspired:

Released in 2003, St. Anger arrived amidst a year of significant global events. The world was witnessing the aftermath of the Iraq War’s onset, and the completion of the Human Genome Project marked a milestone in scientific achievement. In the cultural sphere, films like The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King dominated the box office, reflecting the year’s diverse and transformative landscape.

Five Things about St. Anger

Here are five intriguing facts about St. Anger that underscore its unique place in Metallica’s discography:

Media and Television Usage

Despite its polarizing nature, St. Anger found its way into various media, reflecting its cultural impact.

Critical Reviews and Retrospectives

The critical reception of St. Anger was as diverse as the album itself. While some praised its raw energy, others criticized its departure from Metallica’s signature sound.

The following table summarizes notable reviews and their perspectives:

According to Metacritic, the album holds a score of 65, indicating generally favorable reviews. This mixed reception highlights the album’s complex legacy, as both a bold experiment and a contentious entry in Metallica’s catalog.

After St. Anger

Following the release of St. Anger, Metallica embarked on a journey of reinvention. The band welcomed bassist Robert Trujillo, who brought new energy and stability to the lineup. This period was marked by a renewed focus on live performances, culminating in the release of Death Magnetic in 2008, an album that saw the band return to their thrash metal roots.

As of October 2024, Metallica remains a dominant force in the music industry. Their recent projects include extensive world tours and the release of a new studio album, further solidifying their legacy as one of the most influential bands in heavy metal history.

Remasters and Reissues

The enduring appeal of St. Anger has led to several remasters and reissues, each offering fans a chance to experience the album anew.

These reissues often include remastered audio and exclusive content, providing a richer listening experience. The vinyl release, in particular, has been celebrated for its high-quality sound and vibrant packaging.

Conclusion

In conclusion, St. Anger remains a pivotal chapter in Metallica’s storied career. Its raw sound and unflinching exploration of personal and collective turmoil continue to resonate with fans and critics alike. While the album’s reception was mixed, its influence on the heavy metal genre and its reflection of the band’s resilience ensure its place in music history.

Further Reading

• The Making of The Black Album by Metallica (Blog Article)
• The Making of The Black Album by Metallica (Podcast)

Let us know in the comments what your thoughts are on St. Anger by Metallica. Did we miss anything? Share your experiences and join the conversation!